Alfreton Town
| Nathan Hicks |
| Duane Courtney |
| Lathaniel Rowe-Turner |
| Tom Davies |
| Clifford Byrne |
| Luke Graham |
| Tom Shaw |
| John Johnston |
| Daniel Bradley |
| Karl Hawley |
| Sam Johnson (G) |
| Carl Lamb |
| Jake Sheridan |
| Jordan Keane |
| Anthony Howell |
| Paul Clayton |
Gateshead
| Alex Rodman |
| Phillip Turnbull |
| Jamie Chandler |
| Tom Allen |
| Ben Clark |
| Craig Baxter |
| James Curtis |
| John Oster |
| Matthew Pattison |
| Robert Ramshaw |
| Adam Bartlett (G) |
| Valentin Gjokaj |
| Danny Wright |
| Michael Rankine |
| Lewis Guy |
| Jon Shaw |
